Has the US right-wing media finally gone too far?

Tom Mendelsohn

98450225 300x240 Has the US right wing media finally gone too far?There’s quite the scandal brewing across the Atlantic at the moment, and for once it’s not one Liberals are having to watch through the cracks of their fingers.

It all started a couple of days ago, after right-wing doyen and Internet loudmouth Andrew Breitbart claimed to have uncovered damning video of a (black) Department of Agriculture employee named Shirley Sherrod admitting to discriminating against a white farmer – or not giving ‘the full force’ of her help to him. As you can see from the link, he went ballistic, popping his digital veins in a spittle-flecked rant about ‘racism’ and the hypocrisy of the left.

It was a bad video. She looked as though she was revelling in her apparent racism, at one point saying:

“What he didn’t know while he was taking all that time trying to show me he was superior to me was, I was trying to decide just how much help I was going to give him,” she said. “I was struggling with the fact that so many black people had lost their farmland, and here I was faced with having to help a white person save their land. So I didn’t give him the full force of what I could do. I did enough.”

Breitbart, who has a history of splenetic extreme-right agitation, was using it as a counterpoint to the Left’s constant assault on his beloved Tea Party. Fox News went hard at it, it hit the blogosphere, and suddenly the full machinery of the conservative hate machine was swinging into play. In short order, Shirley Sherrod was sacked by Agriculture Secretary Tom Vilsack, apparently with the cognizance of the White House.

Conservatives didn’t have much time to celebrate their scalp, and their proof that the Left is all up’n racist, because it turned out that the 2:36 of video Breitbart had published was slightly edited. Well, heavily edited. The full video emerged within 48 hours. It was 43 minutes long, and contextualises the anecdote – she related the event because it helped her overcome her own prejudices. She admitted she had been wrong, and was in fact talking about how to beat racism! And, you’ll note, the farmer in question’s wife named Sherrod as a ‘friend for life’.

If nothing else, this demonstrates the current power of the right-wing media in the US at the moment; they can push any old paranoid fantasy out through the gate, and manufacture a storm in the mainstream media, who seem to feel duty-bound to report rumours as fact until shown otherwise.

Cue grovelling apologies from the White House and the Department of Agriculture, and an offer of reinstatement.  It’s not being left at that, though. After months of stoically trying to deflect the Right’s attacks off its own chin, the Left now seems to be gearing up to make this little flashpoint into an actual fight.  Breitbart, who may have done this sort of thing before, stands accused of deliberately distorting the facts, and there’s talk of libel suits and reporting Fox to the FCC. It’s all very exciting, because, as noted, the Left normally just buries its head in the sand at the first sight of partisan media trouble.

Despite all this, and despite all those other times the conservative media has attempted to mould the truth, history tells us that not much will happen. Perhaps Breitbart will get served, and perhaps he’ll have to pay some damages. However, he’s a wealthy man, and he’ll be able to suck it up and keep sounding off, maybe just a little more careful than before, in the full knowledge that even his failed rumours are doing real damage to the Obama administration.

Fox News, meanwhile, will also shrug it off. They’ve already spun on a ha’penny and started howling about how Sherrod shouldn’t have been sacked – yet more demonstration that they run nimble rings around the White House.

Breitbart, for his part, remains unrepentantly belligerent. He’s claiming that the so-called farmer’s so-called wife is a plant. What a gent.

Picture credit: Getty Images

  • Citizen Bidet

    Really? Cheney dying?
    I’m off out for a drink.
    Let me know when a) Thatcher, and b) Murdoch die as I don’t get to go out much these days.

  • Tom Mendelsohn

    Yet again, I’m proved a copy-editing chump. It has been changed. Thanks!

  • Bill

    The shrieking and posturing from the left over the “quoted out of context” problem is utter hypocrisy. Remember the Pope’s discussion of the history of Islam? Remember Margaret Thatcher, being laughed at over her almost universally mis-quoted “there is no such thing as society” quote. Any remorse there? Of course not.

  • Moises Figueroa

    Difficult to comment because no one seems to be responsible for what happened but I think the GOP right wing went too far on this one. I think Fox owe and apology to this lady in person as well as to the nation.

  • Saucy Jack

    And why’s that a good thing?So the US can see some more of his “change”? Hah. I’m no right winger, but Obama is useless.

  • Saucy Jack

    The Pope was right. But I lost all respect for him when I found out he tried to shield kiddy-fiddlers from justice.

  • Tom Mendelsohn

    Two wrongs don’t make a right.

  • Nick Totti

    Everyone already knows America is controlled by bunch of extreme right-wing media since ages. These are the right wing clowns who are responsible to keep America stupid, dumber than dumber, and help rednecks gain more recognition. In return when ever you have Presidents like Bush, Reagan etc, it will be easy to lie to the public, deceive them and get the entire nation to back you up for oil wars.

  • Gary Kline

    “Fox News went hard at it, it hit the blogosphere, and suddenly the full machinery of the conservative hate machine was swinging into play. In short order, Shirley Sherrod was sacked by Agriculture Secretary Tom Vilsack, apparently with the cognizance of the White House.”
    Your story shows your slant with just this one example. The fact is that she was forced to resign before her name was even mentioned on Fox. But don’t let the facts get in the way of your story.

Most viewed



Property search
Browse by area

Latest from Independent journalists on Twitter