Nadal v Federer: Perhaps art can determine who’s the best…

Simon Rice

Nadal v Federer – who’s the best? Federer has more titles but Nadal won three of this year’s majors. Federer is lauded as the greatest of all time but he can’t beat Nadal. It would seem that deciding on a winner is just about impossible. If only there was a fair and unequivocally accurate way of determining it…

Well, we may have just found a leveller – art.

The pair have produced a self portrait as part of the build up to the ATP World Tour Finals which will be taking place at the 02 later this year. Now, I know as much about art as David James, but I’ve been to the Tate Modern a couple of times so for what it’s worth here’s my assessment of the two works…

fed 300x300 Nadal v Federer: Perhaps art can determine whos the best...Roger Federer
The silhouetted image has a strong sense of movement in it, projecting a fluid and stylish approach to his game. Meanwhile the player appears to be gazing ahead, perhaps suggesting that despite past glories the artist might have something to offer in the future. Federer has tellingly selected a couple of colours, blue for the body and yellow for the ball; this suggests a sense of panache, and that he’ll probably do alright at the Australian Open. He also used tennis balls to create the work – a novel approach, but a mark of devotion to his game.

nadal 300x300 Nadal v Federer: Perhaps art can determine whos the best...Rafa Nadal
Nadal has gone for red, a contrast from the cool and calm blue of his competitor. The selected colour could be seen as a nod to his Spanish roots and an indicator he’ll probably win the French Open next year. The pose indicates glory – this is clearly a man at the top of his game and an artist with a sublime back hand. Meanwhile the red splodges appear more densely than that of his rival, conveying a fierce and powerful approach to his art.

So who’s the best ? I’ll let you decide. If it helps, here’s a video showing the pair creating their masterpeices…

The works, along with self portraits of the other six players who qualify for the end of season tournament will go on show ahead of the Finals, before being sold off for charity. Tickets are available for the event and can be found here.

You can follow Simon Rice on Twitter at

Tagged in: , , ,
  • fychan

    What a load of nonsense, even if its for charity.

Most viewed



Property search
Browse by area

Latest from Independent journalists on Twitter