Blogs

Review of Doctor Who ‘The God Complex’

Neela Debnath

Doctor 6 final 300x169 Review of Doctor Who ‘The God Complex’SPOILERS: Do not read this if you have not seen episode 11, series 6/32 of Doctor Who

Toby Whithouse returned to the writer’s chair with an episode that examined faith and in particular Amy’s belief in the Doctor.

Whithouse has written for the show before and his credits include ‘School Reunion’ from series 2/28, which saw the return of Sarah Jane Smith and K-9. He also contributed to last year’s ‘Vampires in Venice’.

‘The God Complex’ was another frightener in a series which has been full of watch-from-behind-the-sofa moments. This episode was just as creepy as ‘Night Terrors’ because it took elements from a whole host of different nightmares: animated ventriloquist dummies, Weeping Angels, social humiliation, letting one’s parents down, etc. Although there was enough horror to disturb younger viewers, this was more focused on the bad dreams of older members of the audience.

Therefore, it was no coincidence that the hotel looked like the set of Stanley Kubrick’s ‘The Shining’. Nor was it by chance that there were odd camera shots used throughout the episode. At times the audience sees the Doctor on a black-and-white CCTV monitor – as if being observed by someone, at other times the alien Minotaur is gazed at through a spy hole, creating a fisheye lens effect. Additionally, there were shots from unusual angles, either from below or uncomfortably close up, which added to the warped tone.

In the tradition of ‘Doctor Who’, the famous face is usually hidden beneath extensive layers of prosthetics and make-up, Sarah Parish as the Empress of the Racnoss in ‘The Runaway Bride’ is just one example. David Walliams’ was unrecognisable as the cowardly Gibbis. Although he gave a fair performance, it was Amara Karan as Rita and Dimitri Leonidas as the conspiracy theory-obsessed nerd, Howie, who really stood out. Rita, the Martha-esque figure, was the voice of reason and saw the Doctor as he truly is: imperfect and fallible. Karan’s performance gave the impression that she could be a future companion, so it was a disappointing when she was killed.

After Rita died, it suddenly dawned upon the Doctor just how much danger he had been putting Rory and Amy in. Consequently, there was a clear shift in Amy and the Doctor’s relationship. He told her to let go of her faith in him and to stop believing that he would always save the day. He knows he has limits and that each of his companions is a liability. So, it was unsurprising when he decided to move on without Rory and Amy. Yet there was sombreness to his farewell.

Nevertheless, the truly sad moment was when he was by himself in the TARDIS; it was a reminder that the Doctor’s life is a solitary one. Despite his cheery outlook, there is an overwhelming sadness to his life that he tries to keep concealed. This scene emphasised that his life is characterised by loneliness punctuated by periods of company.

It seemed odd that Amy so readily accepted that the Doctor was leaving without her and that her daughter was still out there somewhere in time and space. In the past Amy has said that she didn’t want to miss out on those years with her child and yet she seemed to just let go of the one man who could bring Melody back. Has she resigned herself to the fact that maybe the Doctor cannot help? Or does she still have an element of faith left in her “raggedy man”? Last week a version of herself lost her belief in the Doctor but the younger version has not endured what the older one did. Is there the implication that she still thinks that the Doctor will make sure everything ends well?

With the departure of one set of companions, the Doctor re-visits an old one. Craig Owens (James Corden), who was last seen in ‘The Lodger’, will encounter the Doctor again and by the looks of it, there will be some Cybermen to contend with as well.

Image credit: BBC

Tagged in: , ,
  • http://www.facebook.com/carl.rood Carl Rood

    I see The Doctor’s “revelation” as essentially dishonest.  Unless they truly plan a complete change in format, how is going to avoid endangering another companion or two.  Really, if The Fifth Doctor didn’t get the message when Tegan left, why would the Eleventh, who’s far more alien in personality?  Even better, what about Adric’s death?

    I’m seeing this more as being part of his master plan.  The Eleventh seems quite reminiscent of the Seventh.  He lies a lot.  Everything’s part of a larger plan.  

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Matt-Tysoe/711623798 Matt Tysoe

    you just fancy her ;)

  • petefrombaltimore

    i just watched the epsiode for the first time.and im very sad that Rita didnt become a companion of the Doctor .Amara Karan is an incredible actress.and her Rita charachter was great


Property search
Browse by area

Latest from Independent journalists on Twitter