Review of Doctor Who ‘The Wedding of River Song’
A finale that refused to tie up the loose ends neatly and reiterated the point that in the Who universe there are now no hard and fast rules when it comes to time travel.
The climax to this series proved to be brainteaser, with so much going on that it was easy to get lost in the melee. The Doctor didn’t really die instead he was inside the Teselecta which River shot, so he was actually fine. Surely, if the Doctor does not die, it changes a fixed point in time? Apparently, the universe now thinks he is dead, although once he starts turning up the save the day, won’t people will start to realise that he didn’t die? And in a ceremony quicker than a Vegas wedding, River and the Doctor tied the knot but only because it was the only way she would obey him and return to said fixed point in time.
There were also many ominous new riddles from the head of the decapitated Dorium Maldovar (Simon Fisher-Becker). The Doctor learns that on the fields of Trensalor at the fall of the Eleventh, when no living creature can speak falsely or fail to answer, a question will be asked, a question that must never ever be answered. The Silence must fall when the question is asked. The Silence are determined that the question will never be answered and that the Doctor will never reach Trensalor which is why they have been trying to kill him. All of this was mind-boggling and took a while to comprehend. Does the Eleventh refer to the eleventh doctor and is the oldest question going to be: what is the Doctor’s name?
From the multitude of questions thrown up by this enigmatic explanation, it is clear that Steven Moffat is trying to return to the epic story-telling quality that ‘Doctor Who’ once had. In the older series, there were plotlines that would be spread out over several episodes. Moffat has now taken this a step further with tales that span over several series in order to create longevity and maintain momentum. During Russell T. Davies’ tenure as showrunner, the end of each series would be neatly wrapped up and there would be no real momentum to move to the next series. The sense of foresight is important and in fact strengthens the show, building up a sense of continuity in terms of characters. River’s story is intriguing and watching it play out is thoroughly enjoyable.
However, there has been an argument running throughout the series about whether it is too complex for children (let alone adults) to understand. It has certainly been challenging to watch and there are times when the narrative becomes hard to follow. Moffat wants to make it more than just a show about a man with a blue box. But the next series must allow the viewer a moment to pause and catch up with what is going on. It could prove detrimental to continue at this break-neck speed which is already leaving some viewers feeling alienated.
As series finales go, it felt underwhelming in terms of drama yet it was overwhelming in terms of information. Maybe if it had ended on the same cliffhanger note as ‘A Good Man Goes To War’ it would have had more of an electrifying feel. Or if there had been more resolution, it would have worked in the episode’s favour.
Generally this series has been an interesting watch. The Doctor’s dark side has been shown along with the moral responsibilities and dilemmas he has in relation to his companions. The themes and character development has added a richness and depth that the show was lacking before. Sticking with the same characters could have proved to be a fatal error and made the series feel stale but instead it has made the programme feel more multi-layered. In some ways the show has felt more adult yet catering to the needs of the average 10-year-old. Aesthetically, the cheaply-made feel has vanished, now there is a cinematic quality to it which befits the series.
We will next see the Doctor in the Christmas special which will feature Bill Bailey, Claire Skinner, Arabella Weir and Alexander Armstrong.
Image credit: BBCTagged in: Doctor Who series 32, Doctor Who series 6
Recent Posts on Arts
- Friday Book Design Blog: The Ariel Poems, and other seasonal pamphlets
- Children’s book blog – Ask the illustrator: Rebecca Cobb
- Piggott's post: Jacobson, Heller and reflections on "real life"
- Ric Blackshaw tells us Scrawl about his street art enterprise
- Children’s books for November: The Something, The Imaginary and Eren
Latest from Independent journalists on Twitter