Who is “crying out” for a referendum on Europe?

John Rentoul

mtwc 300x221 Who is crying out for a referendum on Europe?We saw it coming but not quite how entertaining it would be when it arrived. The re-opening of the Conservative rift over Europe, that is.

A flat Prime Minister’s Questions today. The Labour leader asked two easy questions.

1. “That Liam Fox: he’s a wrong ‘un; how many more like him have you got?” To which David Cameron stepped out of the Chamber, metaphorically, to make the meta-comment that his opponent should have asked that question the week before.

2. “Unemployment and inflation are going up: your economic policy’s not working, is it?”  To which Cameron, safe in the knowledge that the last time we had high unemployment and inflation people voted Tory in their millions, said Labour didn’t have an alternative. Not true, but it didn’t matter.

The only drama during this bit was provided by the theatrical Ed Balls, who has a good Tory-riling face, and was doing his flatlining gesture, slowly moving his flat hand at eye level horizontally from left to right and back. The noise from the Labour side was loud, too, and Cameron started to get a bit shrieky.

Then it all went quiet for the tense part: a question from the Prime Minister’s own side about Europe. Andrew Rosindell, member for Romford, said the British people were “crying out” for a referendum on the future of Europe and invoked the names of Churchill and Thatcher to accuse Cameron of betraying them by refusing to support the backbench motion.

Cameron is good at this. Drop voice. Understand and share the frustration. Want to bring powers back to Westminster from Brussels. But don’t support holding a referendum “come what may”. But he is up against it on this one, and the Tory benches were sullen and unappeased.

He will get out of it this time. The Leader of the Opposition is not ruthless enough – although I am told it is “not yet decided” – to do a John Smith and go into the same lobby as the Tory Eurosceptics on a “pro-democracy” ticket. I doubt if Labour will even abstain.

So the motion demanding a referendum has no prospect of success. It has also been stripped of any meaning by the proposal made by David Nuttall, and accepted, that the referendum that isn’t going to happen should have three options: in, out, or “renegotiate the terms of [UK] membership in order to create a new relationship based on trade and co‑operation”.

From the clarity of “in or out” we are back to the Wislonian mush of “renegotiation”.

And now the vote has been moved to Monday, to give the troublemakers less time and the Prime Minister, who will be in the country rather than out of it (never a good idea when this sort of thing is going on), more leverage.

Yet the Conservative Party has a price to pay for the madness. Any normal person, looking at the appalling vista of Japanese-style indebted stagnation or 1930s-style depression opening up on the continent, would say: whatever one’s views about the European Union, now is not the time to pull out the can at the bottom of the pyramid. I am all for referendums on constitutional questions. There isn’t a new one at the moment, though, and the prospect of a referendum on UK membership, even if it were set for after the next election, can only add to the sense of instability in the markets.

Rosindell is wrong. The voters are not “crying out” for a referendum. They are grumpy about Europe, as ever, but fearful for the economic future. As David Butler and Austin Ranney say in Referendums Around the World, 1994 (I know), it is a common myth that “the public likes referendums”. They point out that turnouts in referendums are consistently lower than in general elections – sometimes much lower.

Some Conservative MPs, however, seem determined to prove to voters that they are not normal.

It’s as if Tony Marlow, Teresa Gorman and Bill Cash still haunted the Palace of Westminster. Oh. Bill Cash still does.

Tagged in: ,
  • Firozali A.Mulla

    The mighty Red Bull makers may be in the soup but I have no idea how you can take the corporation to the court. I just read Michael Jackson in order to dance the “Moon Dance” used to drink lots of Red Bull the caffien fillled drink on top of the already topped up with Diazipam, Alparazolam, Mood elevators ,doctor’s prescribed drugs, and did not live to tell us what went wrong. What I feel sad is the doctor , his, was always called in to testify how he performed the autopsy, I am bad at English words so correct me please. Now there are jobs here. making the Red Bulls and label them made in Brazil. The pay is good and no one will know Castro will objest or not . Simple all over the mother earth we have created so much noise no one wants to know if the neighbour is hungry. I think that is what the religion taught us, But those days are gone with the writers  of the good books. I thank you This comment is not supposed to be here but I want others to know that there are jobes if only you wake up at 4 am and try these. I thank you Firozali A.Mulla DBA

  • Firozali A.Mulla

    John, You may not like this, say you WILL detest it but I have it so please let us be friends need and thin more on this. In the last two weeks, most major American banks announced their third quarter earnings – each one sending the markets on a rollercoaster ride. But earnings announcements comes with more substance than just quarterly numbers – during earnings conference calls, research analysts from other firms have the opportunity to grill and question the bank executives about their company. With the recent release of the draft Volcker Rule for public commenting, the bank heads got their share of inquiries to weigh in on the proposed rule. The rule, part of the Dodd-Frank Act, is meant to ban proprietary trading (trading for profit) at financial firms in order to remove investment banking and trading risks from the bank’s commercial operations. We rounded up what executives at five top American banks had to say about the Volcker Rule. (The topic was absent from the Wells Fargo conference call).I thank you Firozali A.Mulla DBA

  • Firozali A.Mulla

    John I am not sure this is here but where is it? I feel like vomiting but we have it. Can you digest this. No I know the USA, UK, EU is not here but the message is terrible all of it. Read and come back to me please. A Zimbabwean man has told a court that he hired a prostitute who during the night transformed into a donkey, and that he is now “seriously in love” with the animal, state media said Wednesday.”I think I am also a donkey. I do not know what happened when I left the bar, but I am seriously in love with (the) donkey,” Sunday Moyo told the court, according to The Herald newspaperIn Africa under the trees there sit the man who crack eggs and tell you, ” Now you are free from devil” Give me now 50 $ . I am not amazed at these practices at all. It is fun to read during these depressing times. I thank you Firozali A.Mulla DBA And Do not believe the papers. They want to sell.
    Banks Smell Blood in the Water
    “Word, hold on; instead of messing with our future, open up inside. World, hold on; wonder you will have to answer to the children of the sky.”
    –Bob Sinclar

Most viewed



Property search
Browse by area

Latest from Independent journalists on Twitter