The economic impact of the small firm credit crunch
I’ve been impressed by the Daily Mail’s campaign highlighting the credit squeeze on small and medium size businesses. Popular journalism at its best: clear, passionate and firmly in the broad public interest. The paper should make more of this work in its submissions to Lord Leveson’s inquiry into the press.
This morning the Mail continues to hammer away, putting Sir Mervyn King’s words on Wednesday about the continued credit squeeze on small firms on the front page (right).
But, actually, the Governor of Bank of England and the Mail are not singing from precisely the same hymn book on this.
The Mail says small “firms are being starved of the funds they need to grow, create jobs and drive the economic recovery”. And its editorial today warns that “the only way out of Britain’s economic difficulties is to help private business [including SMEs] grow”.
Yet Sir Mervyn’s comments at this week’s press conference suggest he does not regard easing the flow of credit for small businesses as essential for the wider economic picture:
“It’s pretty obvious that net lending by banks to businesses as a whole has fallen quarter by quarter through 2011. Now we don’t think this is a major issue for large businesses, and therefore really for the level of investment in the UK, which is dominated by big businesses.”
Sir Mervyn accepts that small business owners have been treated disgracefully by the banks. He comes as close as he can to saying that Project Merlin has been a sham because net lending to banks actually fell every quarter last year. But the Governor does not expect that credit assistance for this sector would have much of an impact on investment, and therefore growth, in the British economy.
For the Governor the case for action to help small and medium-sized firms is one of equity, rather than economic efficiency. Perhaps that is one of the reasons why he has refused – to the consternation of the Treasury and at least one of his colleagues on the Monetary Policy Committee – to use the Bank’s balance sheet to play a more active role in easing the flow of credit to SMEs.
Recent Posts on Eagle Eye - Breaking views from commentators -
Most viewed
Read
1How the Mail Online turned us into misogyny addicts
2It was Bayern who denied the Germans victory in the Champions League final, not Chelsea
3Becoming Damien Hirst? You’re not the first
4Victory over Juventus sees Napoli begin to emerge from the shadow of Diego Maradona
5Sri Lanka is a long way from the peace and reconciliation desired by so many
|
|
LATEST NEWS
Latest from Independent journalists on Twitter
