Review of Broadchurch – Series 1, episode 3
It’s been a week since Danny died and the police came close to finding a suspect in episode three, but not close enough.
If you’re annoyed you don’t know whodunit, spare a thought for the actors. Writer Chris Chibnall didn’t tell any of the cast who the killer was when he gave them their scripts. David Tennant apparently kept accosting Chibnall on set saying: “I’m annoyed you won’t tell me and I think you’re absolutely right not to!”
At least there was one thing David Tennant’s character DI Alec Hardy didn’t want to find out this episode- and that was his fragile mental state could lead to death. In a peculiar meet up with the town psychiatrist (who looked more like a local fisherman) in a black beach shack, Hardy was told he would push himself to breaking point if he continues exerting pressure on himself professionally.
But Hardy seemed just fine heaping pressure on other people, with yet more jibes directed at DS Ellie Miller (Olivia Colman) for not being tough enough. It was at this point you wondered whether Hardy did have a point. She seemed wrecked and drawn just from addressing her colleagues about the developments of Danny’s murder. If she was so emotionally attached to the family, why didn’t she withdraw from the case?
She was also outraged that the suspect could be Mark Latimer, Danny’s dad, and angered that Harding was pursuing his line of course because it could “destroy the community” if Mark was the killer. The killer (as in most child murder cases) is most likely to be someone in the family, and you don’t need a psychic to tell you that.
At least she tried to put on a hard front, telling Mark’s mate Nigel to “stop pissing about” because she’d heard from his Mum (cosy, is Broadchurch) he wasn’t where he said he was the night Danny was murdered. Then later she commendably told Hardy she would “piss in a cup and throw it at him” if he got her son to do a reconstruction of the events leading up to Danny’s death. Props to her.
Perhaps Danny was strangled by claustrophobia, so tightly knit is the town. When your 15-year-old daughter knows you’re having it off with the local hotelier, surely there’s got to be something up? Chloe is becoming a more suspicious character. Those thickly-rimmed eyelinered eyes are giving nothing away. But her name doesn’t have an S or R in it, as the BT phone-home psychic predicted to Beth.
It was hard not to sympathise with Beth in this episode. Jodie Whittaker’s portrayal of a mother grieving the loss of her son, distraught that the murderer could be anyone she sees in the street (including her husband) was wrenching. Although it might be nice to stop looking for the killer, as Danny supposedly tells her through Mr Medium, you know she can’t. But it’s hard to know what to make of her pregnancy- if she doesn’t tell Mark in the next episode I think we can assume it’s not his (assuming Mark doesn’t run off with his Ozzie floozy before she has time to).
As for Pauline Quirke, her character is still suspicious. Why was she lying to cover for Mark? More suspect still is her accent. Who from the east end caravans all the way down in Dorset? She’d more likely be found on the sinister Kentish marshes. And don’t forget she is also hiding Danny’s skateboard in her caravan.
Like the windmills planted on the beach in the closing shot, the plot keeps on turning.
Prime suspect: Susan Wright
Oh-no-he-didn’t suspect: Chloe LatimerTagged in: Broadchurch, Chris Chibnall, David Tennant, doctor who, jodie whittaker, Olivia Colman
Recent Posts on Arts
- Friday Book Design Blog: Collier Books - great paperback design... and some of the worst Narnia covers I've seen
- Pulled Apart By Horses' European tour diary
- Friday Book Design Blog: Fitzcarraldo Editions
- Children’s books for October: Meg and Mog, The Demon Dentist and The Whispering Skull
- Friday Book Design Blog: Slightly Foxed and Notting Hill Editions
Latest from Independent journalists on Twitter