Great British Bake Off semi final – Episode 9, Series 5: French Week
Bake Off bid adieu to Beca this week as the Welsh Military Wife crumbled in the semi-final with her unrefined bakes.
Her Glenn-like love of super-sized portions finally got the better of her, and the judges were unimpressed with her Opera Cake and pastry canapes. Adding beetroot juice to her choux pastry in the signature challenge sounded sophisticated, but Mary and Paul said her canapes didn’t have the “wow factor”. Mary cuttingly added: “I’m not finding them memorable”. The show’s editors gave the game away on the showstopper challenge, when a close-up of the judges’ appalled faces as she revealed her bannoffee Opera Cake indicated all too soon that it wasn’t going to be a winner. The artificial taste of the banana and lack of varied textures throughout the layers did not live up to Bake Off final standards.
Ruby looked just about as likely to be sent home going into the final judging. She forgot to line her glass bowl with cling film on the Charlotte Royale technical bake, leaving her swiss rolls smeared with jam. For once I really did feel upset for her, as something quite bad had genuinely gone wrong. She was also in tears at the end, although unlike Beca, even before the results were read out. And the downhearted mood continued as she admitted she was sure somewhere “deep down” she was happy to be in the final, it just hadn’t hit her yet.
The news had evidently hit Frances, as the cunning editors immediately cut away from Ruby lamenting her success to Frances cheerily shrieking “Oh my god, oh my god, I’m in the final!” The clothes designer impressed this week with her ’soap opera’ cake, a clever play on traditional soap flavours lemon and lavender. While the judges praised its appearance, they did warn- as always- that some of the flavours were lost and she risked style over substance. It’s becoming all too predictable now, although the judges could not stop praising her ‘vegetable’ canapes at the beginning, with Paul saying they were “lovely, lovely, lovely- magical”.
Kimberley’s levels of smugness will not doubt inflate even more after being named star baker this week. I was disappointed to see she had gone back to her self-congratulatory ways, but nevertheless she did produce some “scrummy” treats. She excelled with her canapes in the signature bake, and came first in the technical for her beautiful (if not heinously 70s) Charlotte Royale, which was packed to the brim and served perfectly. Her lime and passion fruit opera cake let her down slightly, as the bitterness of the chocolate overpowered the other ingredients. But Mary liked the variety of layers, even if she was sniffy about the “rather modern” polka dot decoration.
It’s Kimberley, Ruby and Frances in the final, and after seeing a sneak-peak tonight I’m dying to know who wins. It looks like they have to craft some sort of wedding cake and a lattice pie. All will be revealed next week, j’espere.Tagged in: Beca Bake Off, Frances Bake Off, Great British Bake Off, Kimberley Bake Off, Mary Berry, Paul Hollywood, Ruby Bake Off
Recent Posts on Arts
- Friday Book Design Blog: Here
- A shouting economic adviser, a Nobel Laureate and a rock star scientist on stage at the Jaipur lit fest
- Children’s book blog – the last post!
- Children’s books for December: Herman’s Letter, The Yeti Files, Greenglass House and Winter Damage
- Friday Book Design Blog: The Ariel Poems, and other seasonal pamphlets
Latest from Independent journalists on Twitter