Anyone who followed the story of Shambo the bull will know how seriously many members of Britain's Hindu community regard the killing of sacred temple cows. Well today a cow belonging to Watford's Hare Krishna community was put down, this time apparently while devotees prayed.
Shortly after 9am this morning police and RSPCA officers served the Bhaktivedanta temple in Watford with a warrant and carried out an on-site slaughter of Gangotri, a 13-year-old Belgian Blue-Jersey cross.
For many the furore over Shambo's slaughter was little more than making a mountain out of a molehill. A lot of people simply couldn't understand why there was so much outrage from some of the Hindu community over the slaughter of a diseased bull.
But putting aside mainstream Hinduism's theological arguments over the sanctity of all life and ahimsa, what made many members of the Hindu community really angry was the perception that the authorities had dealt with the matter in an insensitive and cack-handed way. (In Shambo's case that meant police dragging peaceful monks and nuns away from their own temple as representatives of the Welsh Assembly battered down the door to Shambo's shrine to cart him off to the abattoir.)
This time it seems the authorities have resorted to stealth tactics.
Gangotri, who was taken in by the temple after she was hit and paralysed by a car last year, was put down by the RSPCA because she had contracted some rather nasty bed sores and was in constant pain. To the RSPCA's credit three separate vets all agreed that the animal was suffering and that Gangotri should be euthanised. The temple, meanwhile, says Gangotri has made significant improvements since they began looking after her.
But the stealthy way the lethal injection was carried out is sure to anger the wider Hindu Community. According to Gauri Das, one of the community leaders at the Bhaktivedanta temple, devotees had been given personal assurances yesterday from the RSPCA and police that, due to religious sensitivities, no immediate action over Gangotri would be taken. Instead within 24 hours police and vets had entered the farm while devotees prayed and carried out the slaughter. (The RSPCA, incidentally, refute the idea that they had given any assurances.)
We will have to wait to see whether the backlash over Gangotri is anything like as big as Shambo. My hunch is that, because the animal is dead and not awaiting a death sentence like Shambo was, the response will more muted.
But what will almost certainly happen is that those members of Britain's Hindu community who already believe their specific religious beliefs are treated with contempt by the authorities will feel that once again their concerns were proved right. And that is surely something no one wants.

Well of course nobody wants that, but then again we do all want people to behave according to the law. The RSPCA are not Orwellian vigilantes out to put people's noses out of joint. There has to be respect both ways.
Posted by: Greenman | Friday, 14 December 2007 at 12:36 PM
main thing is of course to respect to everyone and everyones life stile but RSPCA cheated temple and they have be questioned for thier action
Posted by: george | Friday, 14 December 2007 at 04:47 PM
The cow actually wasn't paralyzed; she had gotten a pinched nerve after one of our bulls tried to mount her last year. Her appetite was normal, which is the first indicator that she was not in an unbearable amount of pain. In fact, she died with straw in her mouth, still eating till the end! The RSPCA totally disrespected our community, and even admits that they went in unannounced in order to avoid any obstacles in their execution- is this a sign of sensitivity towards our religion and community as they claim? This has been such a shock to us, to be treated as though our whole existence is insignificant.
Posted by: Rasa | Sunday, 16 December 2007 at 09:10 PM
Presumably the Temple had their own vets. So why can the RSPCA just ignore the vets of the Temple. Do the RSPCA not have to consult the specific vets connected to an animal they are investigating.
I dont like the RSPCA any more, dont get me wrong not just for this incident, but because this is another in a list of harsh dealings they have forced on numerous animal owners. They are quite intimidating in their police style uniforms and their flagrant breach of any polite behavior. There are many questions that about how much of their work is actually legal.
If they made a mistake with this one I hope they get prosecuted. For such a reputable charity it is about time they purged these callous actions and found genuine compassionate gentlemen and lady officers.
Donating to the RSPCA, not me, not any more.
Posted by: Margaret Henderson | Sunday, 16 December 2007 at 09:32 PM
The Rspca have no idea what they have done, the fall out from this will stay with there familys for generations
Posted by: Matt cook | Monday, 24 December 2007 at 12:11 PM
Presumably the RSPCA should start euthanizing any human suffering form bedsores and in pain as we are all after all animals.
Posted by: chemicalscum | Sunday, 10 February 2008 at 12:16 AM
What is pretty amazing, and this has come out from all the chatrooms I have been in now, is that there never was a warrant. The RSPCA pretended to get a warrant, and showed the application to the monks on the basis that it was an order which they had obtained. Incredible though it may seem, this is very far from being the first time that the RSPCA have used subterfuge and dishonesty to enter land. They often pose as bird dealers, get into people's homes - their "expert" vet is always on hand to claim that the birds they buy have a "lack of perching" skill. I've even heard of a case where the RSPCA posed as a police "burglary prevention" unit on order to get into a kennels which had had a series of animal-rights related burglaries!
Posted by: David Tyne | Thursday, 14 February 2008 at 02:34 PM
Your blog entry was very informative. Thanks for your effort. We have started a new site called FaithTube
(http://faithtu.be). It contains religious videos from all around the internet. If you could visit us then it would be great.
Thanks.
Simone.
Posted by: Simone | Wednesday, 30 July 2008 at 01:11 PM