What do you think of the programme so far? Is it working for you? Does it all make sense to you?
Give us your feedback and, just as important, share each other's reactions to the No Diet Diet. Mutual support can be a major aid to successful habit-breaking. Just as many of your bad habits and behaviours may be partly kept in place by other people, so a new circle of friends - who don't expect you to carry on behaving as you have always done - can help you to break free.
So: come here when you need encouragement, or want advice on particular concerns; but come here also to give encouragement and share tips. The more support you can give each other, the easier you will find it to achieve your goals.
(If you would like to join in the programme but missed the book given away with the paper, click here to purchase a copy.)

I am intriguied with the No Diet Diet book i got in the Independent today. Well i need to do something this week so may as well collect all editions, follow the rules and how knows, maybe this time next year i will be less podgy, fitter, healthy, positive and have loads of happiness come my way...... Come on gang lets get to it!
Posted by: Sue Green | Saturday, 05 January 2008 at 12:41 PM
I agree the book was fascinating and seems to make so much sense, I'm looking forward to collecting the set and hoping it will also work for me!
Posted by: Sonya | Saturday, 05 January 2008 at 04:18 PM
Can't wait for tomorrow's guide will be up bright and early- thus breaking a habit, the bright that is!- it all makes sense, I hate change so should prove a challenge, a creature of habit no more!- I hope x
Posted by: Sharon Roberts | Saturday, 05 January 2008 at 05:53 PM
I bought this book before Christmas and have an idea of what is coming up. Yes, it makes sense and I hope it works. I hope posting on here with a group of likeminded people will motivate me to break my habits....I have found it hard to start over Christmas...
Good luck everyone!
Posted by: Teresa Rice | Saturday, 05 January 2008 at 07:53 PM
well, what can I say all the familiar stuff about yo-yo dieting (NOT WORKING) loking forward to to morrows paper. It makes sense about the habits. I watched the half-ton mom on tv this week it was so sad and distressing, whilst i am not in such a state it really made me frightened, about my weight and health.
Posted by: Jenni | Saturday, 05 January 2008 at 09:08 PM
When I saw the advert for this supplement on TV I was thrilled, as I had decided already that 2008 would be the year for me to overcome my overeating habits and have a better relationship with food (and hopefully shed pounds at the same time, it's needed)
I'm wondering though, whether it wouldn't be better for me to buy the book directly, as (althought I like the newspaper) I will realistically not have the time to read much of it - shame on me I know.
What do you think?
Posted by: Patricia D. | Saturday, 05 January 2008 at 10:26 PM
I've got my copy with the paper. I figure, give it a go for free and the book's always out there if I decide I like it. No?
Posted by: Amanda | Sunday, 06 January 2008 at 12:06 AM
I was disappointed that the whole thing does not really include me as I am 63 and the programme seems directed at the middle- aged. I don't even know what URL means-so I suppose I can't join in!
Posted by: Helen Maclenan | Sunday, 06 January 2008 at 12:07 PM
Just read todays booklet I have decided to do the writing task today - Is it alright to swap the order of the task do you think? As long as you complete them all?
Helen - I don't think you should be put off I just ignored the URL box!
Posted by: Sonya | Sunday, 06 January 2008 at 12:30 PM
Amanda - Of course it includes you, or if it doesn't, that's because you choose that it doesn't. Either you want to change or you are absolutely happy with how things are. Now, given that you have not only read the intro but also gone so far as to post here, I believe something attracted you to the possibility of change so to say you are excluded could be an excuse.
I am 55 next month, by the way, and am regularly inspired by stories from people who are much older than you or I and have done things that would have seemed impossible for me when I was 30 yeas younger - running a marathon, writing and publishing a book, for example.
You have more power than you think, and that begins with your power to choose: Engage. Don't engage. But either way it's your choice and not someone else's prohibition.
Live long!
Posted by: alison shutt | Sunday, 06 January 2008 at 12:48 PM
I was wondering about swapping the order of tasks slightly Helen. Some tasks would be better on some days.
It's really got me thinking about changing habits.
Posted by: Colleen | Sunday, 06 January 2008 at 12:59 PM
Sorry, just realised my comment about changing the order was to Sonya. I got confused by the position of the posters name which appears below the post not above it!
Posted by: Colleen | Sunday, 06 January 2008 at 01:04 PM
I am a Changed Grit.
I have read this morning, while lolling about in bed with a bottle of brandy and a box of chocolate biscuits, the Independent guide to being A New Grit.
I realise now that the Old Grit has got into some very bad habits. Lolling about in bed with a delicious selection of broken biscuits from the milk man is one of them. They are bad, Grit, bad. They are a collection of trans fatty things and they are going to do immense harm to your British Museum*.
Right. From this moment on I am A New Grit. I am breaking bad habits. I am following the Independent no diet guide. And if it does not work I will probably ask for my money back.
* bum
Posted by: grit | Sunday, 06 January 2008 at 01:10 PM
Well done Grit I did laugh at you post!
I'm glad you are changing the order of the tasks Colleen a Sunday without TV would be very hard indeed - so I have just spent 15 mins writing a short story about a naughty boy called Stanley. No TV tomorrow!
Posted by: Sonya | Sunday, 06 January 2008 at 01:17 PM
I am very hopeful that at last this is a truly effective way of doing something about my weight problem.So far the ideas sound well researched and make a lot of sense. I have struggled with WW and SW for years losing then putting back on more! 2 Years ago I lost 7 stones using a product called Lipotrim -a nutritionally complete shake 3 times a day . I lost one stone per month and felt great. Once I stopped them and strted eating normally again it all came back. Good luck to us all this week,
Posted by: Teresa | Sunday, 06 January 2008 at 02:12 PM
Well I have started today but only got a television last week so today is no mega challenge!! I guess it gets tougher?!! Can't wait to see how it pans out - I ate my normal lunch. I wonder how much weight we will lose this week?
Posted by: Carolyn | Sunday, 06 January 2008 at 02:19 PM
I have just bought the Sunday Independent because I saw the No Diet Diet advertised on the front cover. It looks great but to my horror I missed out on yesterday's free book which explained the principles. Is there any chance of me getting a copy?
Posted by: Gillian | Sunday, 06 January 2008 at 02:36 PM
Gillian if you collect all the parts I think you will have all the information you need as the book just gives an overview of all the phases.
The second part of the book is on food facts compiled by the British Dietic Assiciation.
Still laughing at Grit's post
..and wondering what Sonya's Stanley got up to!
Posted by: Colleen | Sunday, 06 January 2008 at 02:59 PM
help please
Am I really supposed to be eating as normal?
Posted by: Carolyn | Sunday, 06 January 2008 at 03:00 PM
PS the book gives a useful looking website by the British Dietetic Association
http://www.bdaweightwise.com/
Posted by: Colleen | Sunday, 06 January 2008 at 03:03 PM
There are certainly no instructions at all about what we should be eating.
I think the idea is we will all be enjoying the new habits so much we might think less about food!
Posted by: Colleen | Sunday, 06 January 2008 at 03:06 PM
I read the book yesterday and felt inspired and have today checked out what the tasks are and new things to try. I'm intrigued about not changing what you eat but maybe you get so involved doing new things then food is no longer a major part of your life.
I was also wondering if changing the days you do the tasks makes any difference. I think it will be OK as the whole idea is just to get you out of the habit of doing the same, so it shouldn't matter which day as long as they are acheived daily.
Can't wait till next week to see if anyone has lost weight!
Posted by: Chris | Sunday, 06 January 2008 at 03:31 PM
help please
Am I really supposed to be eating as normal?
Posted by: Carolyn | Sunday, 06 January 2008 at 03:51 PM
I still feel guilty, that is the point isnt it, we are all so hung up about food that a little bit of chocolate and we feel that it is not normal and then feel we have blown it!
Posted by: Carolyn | Sunday, 06 January 2008 at 03:58 PM
Well, Alison, that told me-or I, as you would say.
Posted by: helen | Sunday, 06 January 2008 at 06:47 PM
how do i get hold of saturdays book?i missed it.
Posted by: helen | Sunday, 06 January 2008 at 06:56 PM
I am really geared up and feel really confident that this time I will be able to lose the weight and keep it off! Looking forward to buying tomorrow's paper and to getting started. Good luck to you all!
Posted by: Karen Cherpin | Sunday, 06 January 2008 at 07:47 PM
Carolyn, there is no stipulation about what you eat and for good reason, you can eat what you want to, if you read the book from yesterday then it states that its other factors that alter your weight or affect it. Its all other habits that need to be looked at and changed.
I've got a career change coming up and need to lose weight for it so this appeared at the perfect time for me, don't worry about the age thing Helen, as if its aimed at middle-age I'm no way near that one yet, it seems to be something that can work for any age. The book made lots of sense to me as I remember when I was lighter I was a lot happier and carefree than I am now.
Good luck to all.
Posted by: Emma | Sunday, 06 January 2008 at 08:09 PM
Looking forward to trying this. Read saturday's book - it all seems to make sense. I always did wonder why the most successful at work seemed to be fairly thin...
Posted by: Maury | Sunday, 06 January 2008 at 08:11 PM
i knew as soon as i saw that step one was no television, this was for me. I'm so bored of wanting to change my habits and not doing anything about it. i thought i'd change after getting married, i didn't. i thought i'd change after having a baby, still haven't and caught in the same yo yo dieting traps. knowing i watch too much television and hating myself every evening for not getting out and walking that day, not just for my sake but for my child's sake as well. What a tedious, repetitive cycle. Time for change!
Posted by: becca | Sunday, 06 January 2008 at 08:12 PM
starting tomorrow- mm but that's a Monday...don't all diets start on a Monday? should I break that habit? I know its a no diet diet but confused..have also printed off a food and activity diary from the bda website..bad idea?.....how come its all girls on here then? lol what are we like?! x bon chance
Posted by: Sharon Roberts | Sunday, 06 January 2008 at 08:17 PM
Becca,
Your comments sound so familiar! It's good to know we're all in the same boat. Desperately need to lose some weight and cannot face WW or SW AGAIN!!! So this sounds great and definitely seems to make sense. Can't wait to start feeling happy and healthy again.
Posted by: Karen | Sunday, 06 January 2008 at 09:29 PM
I like how so many people on here are so motivated - it really helps me!
I've decided that tomorrow was not only gonna be no TV day, but also no internet! 15 minutes to "check our things" (I've enrolled my boyfriend in this) and that's it! We're such internet geeks, me on my laptop and him on his PC... I'm sure it's as bad as slumping in front of the telly.
Good luck everyone!
Posted by: Patricia D. | Sunday, 06 January 2008 at 09:45 PM
Technically Sharon it starts today, as today was the day you got the booklet so you could have done your day without something today and spend tomorrow writing your story, but then as it says you can start it anytime you like and take a little longer to do things if you need to.
I'm going to be cutting down my internet time in general as I spend way too much time on here at the moment! (although plan to keep up with this place a little). I did love the story in todays booklet about Joshua who lost 2.5 stone and helped his child with his Aspergers, now thats something!!
Posted by: Emma | Sunday, 06 January 2008 at 10:13 PM
huh? sorry, what has above got to do with the no diet diet?. Yes, Emma I should have started today but had already watched tv- with the kids- before I got the paper...don't like to cheat see! Iam up for this but already thinking what should I eat?!
Posted by: sharon Roberts | Sunday, 06 January 2008 at 10:44 PM
Morning all! No TV - great. A quiet breakfast - time to think. I'm a school teacher - so enjoying this little oasis of time before the busy-ness of the day.
Posted by: Maury (Co. Antrim) | Monday, 07 January 2008 at 07:44 AM
I have been trying to 'change' various aspects of the way I live my life for many years, so really hoping this approach works. It does seem to make good sense, and for some reason I'm finding it really motivating - in fact I feel inclined to do more than just 2 tasks from the list this week!
Posted by: Hilza | Monday, 07 January 2008 at 12:22 PM
Hi everyone
I'm also trying the no TV day today. It's more of a challenge than it would normally be, because I'm working from home and usually like to enjoy my lunch in front of some trashy daytime telly. But instead I've opted for classic fm and reading in my lunch hour. It's amazing how exciting such a small change can be!
I'm really hoping this will help me to break free from the perpetual guilt I feel for being able to lose weight. I too have lost weight with WW only to put it back on again and have since wasted more than £600 a year on slimming clubs and gym memberships trying in vain to lose it all again. Time for a new approach I think...
Good luck everyone!
Posted by: Mary | Monday, 07 January 2008 at 01:06 PM
Didn't watch tele yesterday amazing how much you can do without it.Just completed the 15 min writing task it was brilliant and refreshing . I just love the whole concept of breaking habits and it makes sense. However I'm not looking forward to giving up tea tomorrow aagghhh!!!
Posted by: caroline c | Monday, 07 January 2008 at 01:31 PM
Started yesterday with no TV, and ended up with a beautifully clean, decluttered bedroom, a luxurious bath and an early night with a book! Was too busy to graze all day as I normally would, which was the object of the exercise I suppose. Shocking to realise how much time I spend in front of the TV, or with it on in the background. Tuned in to Radio 3 on the way to work, instead of Radio 4, as one of my mini-tasks. Also hard, as I love Radio 4, but the classical music gave me space to think about the writing task I'm going to do this evening. Definitely think there is something in this, as colleagues actually commented on how upbeat and cheerful I seem today!
Posted by: Amy | Monday, 07 January 2008 at 01:44 PM
I am looking at the booklet for week 2, and am finding it difficult to place myself in any of the categories as the way I behave varies wildly depending on who I am with eg I am a real extrovert with friends, but much quieter at work and very introverted with strangers! Guess I will have to work twice as hard to break double the habits!
Posted by: Sarah | Monday, 07 January 2008 at 01:45 PM
I went to 3 newsagents yesterday all who had sold out of Independent on Sunday!(is everyone trying this perhaps?!) So can someone tell me how I can acquire Phase 1 - cheers!
(I was hoping it would be on the website but not..)
Posted by: Fiona | Monday, 07 January 2008 at 02:06 PM
Sarah- i did the exact same thing, and i cant get hold of it anywhere. i cannot start the plan without phase one (NOT book one) ... could the people at the independant make more available please!
Posted by: Anne | Monday, 07 January 2008 at 02:39 PM
oops! i meant Fiona, not Sarah, sorry!
Posted by: Anne | Monday, 07 January 2008 at 02:40 PM
Sarah, I've also been looking at the next booklet and trying to work out where I am on those tasks, its not easy thats for sure, might have to consult the all knowing (mum) on those! Haven't done my 15 minutes writing yet, but am doing a mini task and reading the paper from start to finish as I never do that (I rarely read the paper full stop).
Posted by: Emma | Monday, 07 January 2008 at 03:15 PM
Amy I too cleaned out my whole wardrobe instead of watching tele last night. Having completed the writing task today I was so energised I cleaned out all the kitchen cupbords too. Hardly thought about food all day just an incredible sense of well being and feeling in control. Still not looking forward to giving up tea tomorrow !!!
Posted by: caroline c | Monday, 07 January 2008 at 03:31 PM
Well, I've made a start on reducing from 12 stone (Ugh!). Yesterday I went for a 6 mile walk, cleared out clothes I haven't worn for a year and made up 4 large bags for Oxfam. I cheated slightly on no TV as I just had to watch Sense and Sensibility and can't remember how to make the DVD recorder work (it's one bit of technology this 63 year old hasn't mastered), but it was only 1 hour and I won't watch TV today at all. Today I started writing my life story (half an hour), have done a pile of ironing, and gone for a brisk walk. I'm going to find it hard to do step 5 as I wake up at around 5 a.m. and start wandering round the house. I think getting up at 4.0 a.m. will make me even more sleep deprived. Perhaps I should break this habit by staying in bed for an extra hour!! Can't wait for the end of the week to hear about people's weight loss!
Posted by: Ruth | Monday, 07 January 2008 at 04:29 PM
I too saw this advertised on TV and am very glad I managed to pick up the first two books. I actually already pledged to cut down on all the cr8p TV that I have been watching as I agree entirely with the book that it is soo easy to just sit and watch whatever is on like a zombie. So tonight I am going to do the ironing (no change there but must use up some calories!), make a salad to eat tomorrow for lunch and play a board game with my boyfriend. Ruth - just seen your post about sleeping in - if you wake up at 5 and dont fancy waking at 4am (who would?!) then why dont you plan to change the part where you start to wander around the house? Instead, if you can, sit with a cuppa in bed, reading some different (as instructued in the diet plan) and write your 15 mins story or write your plan for where you want to be in 12 months time - all from the comfort of the duvet! Good luck everyone - this is going to turn us into interesting people, as we were born to be!
Posted by: Anna | Monday, 07 January 2008 at 04:45 PM
Good ideas Anna! If I stay in bed but do some of the constructive things you suggest instead of getting up and thinking about what I'm going to eat for breakfast, lunch and dinner I may become less food fixated! I'll start tomorrow!
Posted by: Ruth | Monday, 07 January 2008 at 04:57 PM
Hi All
Just started today - NO TV - what a challenge, I'm enjoying every minute of this. I guess it's to do with being in control, all these tasks are showing us that we have choices and it's up to us if we want to succeed. Weirdly though I am thinking about what to eat or not eat, must be years of guilt about food. I'm looking forward to our results.
Posted by: Helen Connolly | Monday, 07 January 2008 at 04:59 PM