You are here : Home » IndyBlogs Home

 Subscribe to RSS

« Shopping Bag: Running Ahead | Main | Cyclotherapy: Bamboo Revolution »

Sunday, 27 April 2008

Diplomatic Licence: Hello Dalai

By Anne Penketh

China's offer of talks with representatives of the Dalai Lama "in the coming days", which was reported prominently by the Chinese official media, garnered some positive headlines for the Chinese government in the West over the weekend, as Beijing appeared to be yielding to the international calls for a dialogue to avert a boycott of the Olympic Games.

The Foreign Secretary David Miliband said the development was "positive" but the Dalai Lama was much more cautious. So there is daylight between the West and the Dalai's people on this. 

China is well aware that Western governments value trade with Beijing too highly to sacrifice relations on the altar of Tibet, but is prepared to go some way to meet their human rights demands in order to save face at the Olympic Games. But the Tibetan government in exile is holding out for more. Its prime minister, Samdong Rinpoche said it would require "normalcy" in Tibetan areas for the formal resumption of talks with China, and called for a halt in the vilification of the Dalai Lama.

So far those demands have gone unheeded, and today, China was back in default mode, accusing the spiritual leader of being behind the unrest in Tibet, and saying that his real goal is independence. The Free Tibet Campaign wants China to take a number of concrete steps to demonstrate that it is prepared to move forward on the Tibet issue, including withdrawing the Olympic torch relay from Tibet, readmitting foreign media, and releasing all Tibetans detained since violence broke out on 10 March.

The Dalai himself will be in Britain on a week-long trip from 22 May, which will give him an opportunity of briefing government officials on his position. The parliamentary Foreign Affairs Committee has called him in to testify on Tibet human rights. He'll be speaking at the Albert Hall on 22 May and holding five days of teaching at the Nottingham arena over the bank holiday weekend.

Comments

Post-colonial countries still have no shame. You forget to mention that Dalai Lama is a relic of Britain and USA's attempt to carve out a part of China in the wake of WWII. Empire building. Now you give him a platform still, trying to annoy, to put down, to separate the China of today. China today is the tame elephant in the room. Do not be so foolish as to do the same stupid stunts you tried before the return of Hong Kong 1997. Colonial Britain has no moral high ground. Dalai Lama can always be found again, like the Sultans' cousins who collaborated to let you annex the Federated Malay States, or the Majarajahs' pretenders. Swish!!! Rule Britainnia no more.

Why shouldn't the torch relay pass Tibet? It is still Chinese territory. Why are you advocating racism and racial segregation? The torch will pass everywhere in China but Tibet Autonomous Region? What does that say to you? Freedom to Tibet? Sounds more like racism preached by the same people who enslaved black Africans in US and participated in human trafficking. I wonder why only exiled Tibetans complain about human rights. Why the other 54 ethnic minorities are not out there killing Hans? Why the bad bad Han Chinese singled out Tibetans to perform "human rights abuses"? Because all this is made up by Dalai to get more money. He's a beggar, nothing more. Get a job, make an honest living. Stop scamming people.

It's so ridiculous that the Tibetan exile terrorists are called "the Tibetan government". They are not Tibetan! They do not represent Tibet! Why are they always blaming Han Chinese for everything? Whose fault is it when they don't learn to read and write? Whose fault is it when they don't want to work? They were exiled because they are terrorists. It's better they are living in your country, much safer in China.

Dalai's claim of "cultural genocide" is based on his assessment of the new railway "the central government is transporting beggars and handicapped Han Chinese into Tibet. And they also send uneducated prostitutes so that they can spread AIDS to kill Tibetans." Go look it up, his comments were recorded. Sounds ridiculous? This is a man who's a living God? He's a man who preaches only peace? Just a few days ago, Dorje Shugden, one of the Tibetan deities, sued Dalai for religious persecution in India. This particular deity is one of the 5 main Tibetan buddhism lines. And Dalai has decided he is to be the only one to be worshiped by all Tibetans. These other lamas have been chased and killed in India in the Tibetan exile communities. It's on youtube.com, this piece of news is not picked up by mainstream media, I wonder why! It's happening again, another terrorist group (the Dalai clique) has been created. One day, this group will turn its violence directed at Chinese today to those who created them. Saddam, Bin Laden, etc. are the few examples. Do you ever ask why they bite the hands that fed them?

Supporting terrorism is never justified. It will only come back and haunt you!

Ahhh...more post-colonial moanings.

In case you haven't noticed the world has moved beyond colonialism. What it comes down to is that Tibetans and many others living in China cannot speak freely (as you have done). They cannot sing certain songs without fear of arrest, they cannot practice their religion, they cannot even teach children certain values without being publicly shamed.

Talk all you want about the past my friend, but you better wake soon and realize that if you live in China, you are not a free person.

What the Tibetans and the Dalai Lama are asking for is the same thing we (including yourself) should all be asking for...free speech, free religion, free press and free expression.

The Dalai Lama is no relic of anything western, for centuries he has been a spiritual icon revered by millions in Tibet. No matter how hard anyone tries to criminalize him, or paint him as a CIA agent, the truth remains. If you want to see a lama that is a political fabrication look no further than the Chinese installation of the Panchen Lama after they kidnapped the original.

With all the nasty things happening in this world you can only sit here and moan about what the British did 60 years ago, as if that somehow justifies oppression in the 21st century.

Absurd.

Dorje Shugden, a Tibetan deity, just sued the Dalai Lama?!

Now really, can we believe anything else this idiot says?

Yeah, maybe God has just decided it is more profitable to just sue those who offend him, rather than smite them down.

But really this Shugden business is the only thing the Chinese have in their hats to villify the Dalai Lama, and it obviously is an issue they don't understand. The Dalai Lama himself used to worship Shugden, but he later declared that it was not a wise practice as Shugden is a violent diety. Now, doesn't that prove the opposite of what these Chinese are trying to prove, that the Dalai Lama is some sort of terrorist mastermind on par with Bin Laden. Hah!

I am guessing the Buddha, Lao Tzu and Allah will soon be suing this guy's ass for being such a completely mindless cadre.

HAHA!

Yes, a Nobel Peace Prize winner should start looking for an honest job. I guess being the world's most respected spiritual icon just doesn't get the respect it once did now that the Chinese have the moral high ground.


"this Shugden business is the only thing the Chinese have in their hats to villify the Dalai Lama"??? It's not the Chinese who are bringing this up. It's the Tibetans in India! They are suing in Indian courts!!! Oh, I guess it's convenient for you now to call them "Chinese" to support your argument. Come on, pick a side! Either support Tibet-independent or support One-China.

Oh Shugden is a violent deity. So you say. The lamas are violent??? No way! They are peace lovers!!! Let's say that's true, so it's ok for Dalai to call on his supporters to kill??? To kill in the name of religion??? Hmm, I think we have all heard of this before. What has the deity done relating to violence??? Where is the evidence??? Just because Dalai says so, it doesn't mean it's true.

BTW, Lao Tzu did not ever claim he was God, but a philosopher. If you don't know anything, stop spreading lies. Listen and read once in a while.

It's so funny so hear "if you live in China, then you are not free. " Really? If free means being stupid and racist, then there is no such encouragement in China for this kind of crap. Next time when you see Chinese tourists raiding your upscale shops, ask them if they are free! They are free enough to buy the overpriced crap you make!

"In case you haven't noticed the world has moved beyond colonialism." Oh really? What's happening in Iraq??? People are killed for nothing, or more importantly for oil. Why are the American and NATO troops there? The same groups of people who precisely committed "colonialism" in the past. It's so funny that people can't talk about past colonialism. Why is it then it's applauded when Obama gave the speech on racism? Why even mention that? Slavery is a thing of the past. Why bring that up? What you are saying is since slavery and colonialism are in the past, we should encourage them again? Or just pretend they never happened? I wonder if the African Americans agree with that.

Info on "this Shugden business":

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tenzin_Gyatso,_14th_Dalai_Lama


Just do a google search.

China has no moral high ground, it is awash in a flood of sins against it's own populace- how sad that the promises made to bring the peasantry forward into the light of civilization have left them starving in their fields to support a new class of rich tyrants- tactics learned from western republicans have been applied to consummation, cynically exploiting those at the bottom of the social structure with the cruelest lie of all- hope for progress. Looks like the "great leap forwards" was nothing but a greed-inspired lunge at the brass ring, hoping for another free ride on the shoulders of the oppressed. Tibet could have a much greater degree of autonomy as a cultural clade without threatening the Chinese government, but that cannot be allowed because it might inspire a misperception of the potential for freedom amongst the rest of the enslaved. Attempting to sling mud at one of the foremost religious authorities alive today would be hilarious if so many people weren't blind to the irony of a literally murderous government impugning a group of people who simply wish to be left alone.

"murderous government impugning a group of people who simply wish to be left alone". The murderous government is the Bush administration supported by people like you. Yeah, another 100 years for the war in Iraq. Great! Iraqis just don't want to be left alone, they love the company.

Obama is right "when people are bitter, they cling to guns and religion". You are just bitter, pissed off at the world because you don't have your "American dream". Let's blame the Chinese for this! Why not, you got to blame someone, better someone else than yourself.

BTW, I don't see Jesus Christ walking down the street and giving speeches to beg for money. Actually, did the Pope do that last week when he was in the US? Did Bush give him money? Oh I forgot, he apologized for the priests who raped boys and talked to Jewish rabbis. Hmm... I guess the Pope didn't need to be a beggar. He has support from billions, not 100k exiled terrorists.

Arafat also received a nobel peace price. I wonder if the Israelis consider him a living god. Why don't the Israelis just talk to him??? What? We do not negotiate with terrorists! Right, Chinese don't do that either. And I recall Jimmy Carter actually had a job or two, like being the President? How dare him have a job! He should just go around and beg too. How could one ask those nobel price winners to work??? What, they don't need to? Because they got money from the Nobel committee? What? A million? I think that amount is enough to build your American dream, you should go and ask Dalai for that money.

Desmond Tutu? Also a peace price winner. So what's been happening in South Africa? Yes, apartheid was over. But why does so much violence still exist there? Oh, they are just trying to drive out all the whites! 40+% of South Africans are HIV positive or have AIDS. Why isn't he out there advocating this cause? Don't want to talk about it??? Why not??? Why do you have the free time to preach about China? Start working on things that actually are close to you, surround you. Stop pointing fingers across half of the globe on things and places that you don't know about and have never been.

Dalai has not been in China or TAR for 50 years. He was invited back to settle in the 80s as the leader of the TAR region. He refused because for financial reasons, he needed to do the work that his handlers told him to do. See, he did have a job, made money, blood money that is. Now he wants "real autonomy" for Tibetans in Tibet and in half of China, not independence. Oh yeah? I guess you forgot you were offered that 20+ years ago? I guess China was too poor back then to have HH back, now the Pogala palace has been restored to perfection, you want to be back? Guess what? You can't. Too bad for you! Cry me a river! You can stay in India, or just move to Paris where you just gained Citizenship. China is not going to pay for you to sit on your royal highness all day. Yes, you take our money, you work for us.

Dear Chinese people who read this blog - you don't have to listen to these post colonial mutterings of these Brits, their own country is in a mess and run by foreigners and the only reason they speak so loud is because unlike any other imperialistic power including the Nazis, they can never admit to their own wrong-doings in stealing territory from other nations. This pro Tibet nonsense is nothing to them, most of them have only read about Tibet in fairy stories and brain washing from their own propaganda newspapers. If the USA or Britain had possession of Tibet now then that would be just fine. Maybe they should give Scotland their independence - most of the Scots hate the English..... Also all the crocodile tears when they had to give Hong Kong back in 1997, saying goodbye to all the money they got out of the hard working Chinese...thank God those days are over. Brits are lazy and want it all THEIR way, sorry the party is over Blighty.

The Dalai Lama epitomises peace and reason. TT: Suggesting that he calls on his supporters "to kill in the name of religion" is wildly ridiculous. You have not even tried to justify this fantastic claim.

His Holiness unilaterally gave up campaigning for Tibetan independence, in favour of an autonomous administrative region within China, which showed his commitment to conciliation and practicality.

This was despite the fact that China's invasion in 1950 was quite illegal, and that unbelievable brutality has been perpetrated against the indigenous people of Tibet in the years since then.

Regarding Dorje Shugden, my understanding is that the Dalai Lama said that this is a wrathful earthly deity with whom peace-loving Buddhists should not associate. Today only one breakaway sect continues the practice.


Yes, you would expect abuses, the way everybody, regardless of ethnicity, suffers in a major revolution. The revolution started with the Taiping Rebellion in 1861 and isn't over yet! But does that mean the whole country of China must be balkanized the way Yugoslavia has been, which is in the keen interest of western powers so they can run the country with a puppet government? I read all this biased email from both sides and I am appalled by people shooting my mouths off out of ignorance. Nevertheless, Tibet has been indisputedly a part of China since the Yuan (Mongol) Dynasty in the 13th century, with a hiatus between 1912 and 1950 due to unrecognized treaties signed behind China’s back. Then the Brits and Russians wanted to carve up Xinjiang, Tibet, India, Afghanistan, all in their own interests. Just look at the border of Afghanistan --- what a contorted mess! Losing Outer Mongolia to the Russians was bad enough. Lastly, if I lived in a country with 1.3 billion people and my watershed were to fall into the control of an unfriendly power (all major glaciers reside in Tibet and Xinjiang), what would I do? I'd fight like hell to keep it as a buffer for my survival. It's not a matter of supporting one regime over another --- it's pure survival. Lastly, if every ethnic group wanted their own land, there'd be 1 million "countries" all over the world, all fighting each other. Chinese people realized this 4000 years ago, and heralded the creation of the first nation state under the Chin Dynasty as a major event --- a concept they hold sacred down through the cycling of dynasties. The “One China” policy didn’t originate with the Chinese government today.

Well, although I am shocked by the "Free Tibet" movement's violent protests and riots, and their outrageous unsubstantiated accusations, I do think China has a right to respond. If I understand correctly, these current riots are designed and paid for by Foreign Organizations, including the NED and funded by the Richy-Richs of the world, and even the US Congress. The Dalai Lama is, according to US documents and Congressional Record, an instrument of the OSS, CIA, NED, and the UD State Department. If you compare his current words on this issue, reported in the press, and compare them with speeches made by US Congressmen and women, you will see he is repeating their words. It is fair to raise an eyebrow that the Dalai Lama would allow himself to become the mouthpiece for another "democracy revolution" based on propaganda and, yes, even violent "opps."

However, let's do look at China's human rights record. In 1951 China met with Dalai Lama's reps and signed 17 point agreement providing for autonomy for "Tibet" and peaceful change of the serf-slave based system. The Dalai Lama and his family responded by having the CIA train commandos and engaged in secret contra terrorist attacks against the Chinese, who were building roads, schools and hospitals. In 1959, the Dalai Lama agreed to leave Lhasa, accepting a $180,000 yearly retainer, and further agreed to set up 10 terrorist camps in Mustang, in Nepal, for the purpose of invading and killing, and harassing China. The Chinese freed the Tibetans the Dalai Lama abandoned, the people of Tibet, 90% of whom were serfs, and 5% of whom were house slaves.

The Cultural revolution was a huge setback, but was not targeted at Tibet. In fact, China has apologised abjectly for the damage done, and has made reparations. Has the dalai Lama apologized for slavery of the Tibetan people?

The Dalai Lama unfairly accuses China for genocide, claiming that they killed a million Tibetans. However, when he left there were 1.2 million Tibetans, and today there are more than 2.6 million Tibetans. How could there be so many Tibetans today id China had killed almost the whole population of Tibet in 1959? This is just another example of what people mean when they say the Dalai Lama lies.

The Dalai Lama says that China is destroying Tibetan Culture and language. However, this too, is not true. China has built schools for the Children of Tibet, in Tibet. China, unlike Australia and the US, did not remove children from their families in Tibet, brought the schools to Tibet. The chiildren learn to read and write Tibetan language, and habve free 9 years compulsory education.

Under the Dalai Lama serfs and slaves had no education. His family alone owned over 6000 field serfs and 109 house slaves. they had no rights to an education, no rights to choose to marry, and no rights to choose what to believe. there was no religious freedom at all. Little boys, as young as two years old, were confiscated by monks, to be raised by monks in the monasteries.

The first law that was passed after Mao came to power, was the Marriage Law, effective May 1, 1950. This gave women equal rights, and protected children. It was passed due to "the mother of China" Soong Ching Lings persistence, and Mao's commitment to women’s rights. Under the Dalai Lama, women were thrown out of the house to have childbirth in the dirt, because it was considered unclean to have babies in the house, and if she gave birth to twing, they were confiscated and killed by the monks, as proof she had "consorted with evil spirits."

Live expectancy under the Dalai Lama was 35 years, today, in "Tibet" it is 67 years. China has affirmative action for Nationalities, what they refer to as minorities, and Tibetans are accepted into schools and colleges with lower test scores than Han. China has improved the standard of living in Tibet, bringing roads and telephones, to far flung farm villages and herders, and people live in homes. Under the Dalai Lama almost a million people "lived rough" as serfs.

China does not use corporal punishment, and children in school are not beaten with long sticks as they were under the Dalai Lama. Parents, not Monks are responsible for the behavior and upbringing of their children. China closed the dungeons and torture chambers in the monasteries, where under the Dalai Lama punishments for even minor crimes included gouging out eves, cutting off arms or legs, pulling the fingers out from the hands, and even peeling off the skin.

China ended the onerous corvee system, where serfs who couldn't pay had to sell their children, and ended the "ear tax" where serfs who didn't want to serve in the Dalai Lama's militias would have to pay by having one ear cut off. China does have sedition as a crime, punished with prison term or education, but under the Dalai Lama anyone who even complained, or expressed an opinion against the Dalai lama would have his tongue cut out.

China says they have made much progress with both economic and human rights, but they are not perfect and need more time. They have identified areas of concern, and are working on it. These are not just words, but on record, and funds and agencies are set up to carry out goals set by the people. The Dalai Lama refuses to acknowledge any shortcomings, n as failed to understand, much less offer a meaningful apology for what most would think were atrocities, never mind human rights abuses. The Dalai Lama continues to blame others, and demonize China, all the while projecting his own unacceptable behavior on a people and government who have spared no effort in bringing a better life to the people in Tibet.

Therefore, I encourage China to take up the gauntlet thrown across their face, and use this as an opportunity to highlight their huge progress in human rights, especially in Tibet. And, if the western press continues to refuse to look at China's human rights record, and progress, and continues to repeat the propaganda authored in the US congress and pouring out of the Dalai lama's mouth, then I and milllions of others will turn to Anti-Cnn for the truth.

Remember, a democracy depends on a free press, and the people have a right to know. Propaganda, even delivered by monks, is still propaganda, and a barrier to understanding and achieving human rights.

take care

Kathy and Shannon

Danno, I can read between the lines of lunatic ravings and clearly see your hatred of the British knows no bounds.

I just wanted to let you know that as a Scotsman I dont hate the English and contrary to what the SNP would have everyone believe the people of Scotland are not desperate to break up the Union. The SNP recieved just 41% of the vote and only 39% of the elegible voters bothered to vote in what was hailed as a great turn out.

And I really am beginning to despise this constant line from foreigners that our colonial past is somehow built in to our very DNA. Sorry to dissapoint you, but I wasnt around during Queens Victorias reign and whatever those Victorians got up to has nothing to do with me. I feel not on ejot of guilt whatsoever. But I am proud to be British..So there!

Danno, your a rather hateful person arnt you.

I do not hate you at all, in fact I have no feelings for you, I don't care about your country and please leave China to be itself and to look after our own territory - you people stick your nose into everything and yes, your colonial history stinks, live with it. We do not like your imperialistic attitudes and please go and re build Iraq because you and the Yanks have bombed the hell out of it. We have given Tibet a successful economy and NO BOMBS!!! Get it?

Kathy and Shannon,

Whatever was wrong under the old Tibetan system was probably less bad than what went on in many less-developed countries in the first half of the 20th century.

Since then China has continued to use the most barbaric torture, not to mention the widespread killings that happened during the Cultural Revolution.

While the number of people living in Tibet may have increased, that merely reflects the vast numbers of ethnic Chinese who have been resettled there, in an apparent attempt to swamp the indigenous culture.

Now what could be more colonial than that?

Unfortunately some groups in the west seem to be fostered by the Chinese government for the purposes of propaganda.

Wrong Mark....and do you know that three quarters of Tibetan people have left Tibet to work in Mainland China voluntarily to make money for TIBET! You are so mis-informed Mark...and in Chinese university we are taught to respect all ethnic cultures and we must give preference to their needs over our own all the time. You know NOTHING because you like all these others who are just brain washed into your thinking that you have a superior knowledge of the situation by virtue of being WESTERN eh? I have taken the new train into Tibet and the Tibetans love it, the travel, the better economic situation. I guess you are like one of those pseudo western Tibetan Buddhists who are living still with a VERY old fashioned idea of China and Tibet; please ask educated Chinese people about China...torture? Where in the hell do you get that idea? Maybe from Guantanamo Bay or the way the British torture the Iraqis in Basra? You are wrong and brain washed without knowing it because your education is making you think you know better than the people of the nation you are going on about. It is called imperialistic arrogance.

oh i just got it too, Mark said 'groups in the west seem to be fostered by Chinese government for uses of propaganda' so he is thinking i am probably from this kind of group - sorry to disappoint you but no...but it shows how you think of us Chinese people eh? No mind of our own? Can't make comments about our own country? Must take advice and superior knowledge from you? If we do comment then we must be from a Chinese government propaganda group...actually truth is most Chinese people don't read things like this , they are too busy having a happy life IN CHINA. I like to study western thinking and it is very shocking to see how you all think.

@Mark_1V

1. What went on in Tibet was not acceptable in the 20th century. The real question is, however, is who put an end to it? The brits? The Americans? The Russ? The Nazies? The Republic of China? No. Perhaps you are right, after all, the reason the US arrived in Lhasa in 1942 was not to end slavery and bring democracy to the oppressed Tibetan people and trhough out a barbaric corrupt theocracy led by a child "god", no it was to protect Englands Tea Plantations, and the War Lord's drug running.

So, again, my post is examining China's human rights record in Tibet after 1949. Compare it with the Dalai Lama's record. The Dalai Lama had the opportunity, and Mao's complete support to partner in bringing human rights to Tibet, peacefully, over a period of time, without removing the office of the Dalai lama and with Full Atonomy. The Dalai Lama took the m oney and ran. He did nothing to bring human rights to "his" people. In fact he removed all the wealth of Tibet when he "fled" (his responsibilities) a great opportunity. Now, he continues to lie, even about that. (Of course he is on retainer to lie, so what can one expect?")

2. You wsrote >>Since then China has continued to use the most barbaric torture, not to mention the widespread killings that happened during the Cultural Revolution<<

I am not sure you understood what I wrote. It was the Dalai lama that tortured the tibetan people, not the Chinese? In fact there are three torture chambers with dungeons in the Ptola Palace alone, right under his thrown room! There are photos of tortured Tibetan people in a book he approved for publication. It is China, not the Dalai Lama that put an end to torture in Tibet.

The cultural revolution ended 35 years ago. China has taken responsibility for this, apologised and has made and continues to make reparations. The cultural revolutions was not targeted against tibet, nor tibetan people, by the Chinese Gov. It was a political movement, the liberals against the conservatives. The conservatives won, Nixon recognized China, and now we have development along the capitolists ideal of the open market system. Neither the liberals nor the conservitives, however, defended the atrocities committed in Tibet under Dalai Lama theocracy, and no one in China today wants to see a return to the dark ages in Tibet. The point being, Chjina has acknowledged its responsibility for mistakes during the cultural revolution, and is holding itself accountable, while the Dalai Lama refuses to acknowledge for the atrocities that he allowed to contibnue between 1951-1959.

3. The number of ethnic Tibetans living in "Tibet" today is recorded on the census, it shows that today, after the passage of several decades, there are over 2.61 million people in the region. They include roughly 2.41 million of the Tibetan ethnic group (92.2 per cent of the total), 154,360 who are Han (5.9 per cent), and 49,710 of other ethnic groups (1.9 per cent). That would include Hui.

Furthermore, China has a olne child policy for Han Chinese, only. Here are the 2000 stats for fertility rate. China is NOT trying to swamp the minorities. That is another example of the propaganda that pours out of the Dalai Lama's mouth....Today...Total fertility rate: 1.75 (avg. births per woman in childbearing years) (2007)
According to the 2000 census, the TFR was 1.22 (0.86 for cities, 1.08 for towns and 1.43 for villages/outposts). Beijing had the lowest TFR at 0.67, while Guizhou had the highest at 2.19. It should be noted that Xiangyang district of Jiamusi city (Heilongjiang) have a TFR of 0.41, which is the lowest TFR recorded anywhere in the world in recorded history. Other extreme low TFR counties are: 0.43 in the Heping district of Tianjin city (Tianjin), and 0.46 in the Mawei district of Fuzhou city (Fujian). At the other end TFR was 3.96 in Geji County (Tibet), 4.07 in Jiali County (Tibet), and 5.47 in Baqing County (Tibet).[4]

This shows clearly that the percent of total population represented by Han Chinese is decreasing, not increasing. Today in the US, the population of ethnic Chinese is just over 4%. Therefore the political candidates ignore ethnic Chinese. Ethnoic Tibetens make up more than 90% of the population of Tibet. Are you advocating ethnic clensing?

The Brits and French were colonial. They took the land, for plantations, and not unlike the Dalai Lama, worked the land with the local people being only one step above serfs. China ended this Over Lords rule system, where all the land is owned by a few, and the people work as serfs. China did execute land reform, and free the serfs, and the people now earn their own living, and make their own decisions. This is not colonialism. The Dalai Lama's way is colonialism, wrapped up in monks ropes.

Groups in the US have been fostered by the US gov, thru the privitized CIA, namely NED, and other NGO's, including but not limited to the Albert Einstein Institution (AEI), which is funded by Soros foundations and the US government, which provided advise and training for the violent riots this year. In fact, two training manuals were translated into Tibetan, and one has a forward by the Dalai Lama.

This information comes froms one's elected representatives in Congress, not from the Chinese gov.

Again, China should be proud of her human rights record in Tibet, and as a person who cares about social justice, I hope we could all encourage China to continue on this path, which has brought so much improvement to the lives of a people who were slaves only 50 years ago.

The Dalai Lama, in my opinion, should seek the peace is is so fond of talking of, by cutting all relationships with the CIA, NED, and US and other Governments, and return to his studies and practice as a monk. Perhaps he may come someday to be able to accept things as they are, and his role in that. Perhaps he will some day be able to accept responsibility for the atrocities he has allowed, and begin to use his millions, billions of dollars to pay restitution to all those whose lives have been shattered by his mistakes in judgement. But I do not see why China should sit down and negociate with a paid CIA opperative? It makes no sense to me.

take care
Kathy and Shannon


.

Entertainment is often noted for its ability to distract from the sometimes painful issues of the real world. Thanks to all who have provided so many fine if not always short works of fiction (you know who you are) to divert me from an otherwise boring evening. I especially enjoyed some of the pseudonyms provided to protect the, err, innocent- "tt" (perhaps acronymic for "Terminate Tibet", "Totalitarian Tool" or perhaps "Trash Talking"?) is probably my favorite so far. Oh, my goodness (let me save you the trouble of describing that as a short subject); nobody said the leadership of other countries was pure or innocent of less than humanitarian agendas- in fact, given the trade deficits between China and most other countries and the volume at which money talks it might even be implicitly assumed that the Chinese "government" drives some of the less pleasant policies behind the World Bank. Regardless- my congratulations on a professionally orchestrated damage amelioration campaign. Just as a matter of curiosity, I wonder how many of these rabidly "Pro-China" posts are really from the same person? It doesn't matter that much; enough of us still do our own research and draw our own conclusions, regardless of any probably well-paid effort to blind us. I rejoice that free thinkers still exist in numbers sufficient to publicly declaim to any naked Emperor that he has no clothes. Most of us just don't have the easy access to funding that "graces" the ethically bankrupt, and we sometimes get lost in the noise a hired "crowd" can generate. But... not always. Cheers! It's been fun.

I see rent-a-mob arrived here in force?

The concentrated hatred and viciousness of postings from "Danno" and "TT" (the usual anonymous Commissars) is particularly revealing... the rhetoric of the Secret Policeman.

Let's put things in perspective. Since our Chinese "friends" here like to give "history lessons" (from the approved teachings of the COMMUNIST PARTY OF CHINA only) then let's continue the lessons.

In the C20th, 47 million people were deliberately murdered in China by the Communist Party (the party which remains in power today, and has never faced an investigation into these atrocities). The exact number of dead may in fact be higher, but the convenience of a one-party State has enabled the true statistics to be hidden from the Chinese people. Of course Mr Heart-Of-Hatred Danno, or his paid-to-post Commissar friend "TT" will deny these figures - but a Secret Policeman is paid to deny the murders he's committed, of course.

To this day, China is ruled by an unelected antidemocratic COMMUNIST PARTY. There is no law in China - "law" is simply what the unelected thugs of the Communist Party decide. You can see CPC members writing in the messages above.

The sad irony here is that the huge majority of China's population are cheerful, friendly and peace-loving people. The image of China has been ruined by a small gang of thugs, secret policemen, commissars, and Party Members who tyrannise their own people.

The Beijing Olympics could have been a marvellous chance to show China's traditions of peace to the world, and encourage greater understanding of Chinese culture.

Instead, what image remains? The shouting angry threats of Danno and TT, and a group of paid Communist Party thugs in blue tracksuits "guarding" their idiotic Olympic Flame.

No better picture of the Communist-Run Police State of China could have been portrayed if their dumbhead Commie goons had planned it for years before.

The people of China deserve BETTER than you, Danno. I feel sorry for your family when you and your Party are overthrown by the Chinese people - blood is such an ugly thing to see.

I do think we need to learn more about the Tibetan history and the true situation in Tibet before passing the judgement. Not likely we will get the truth through the main-stream media. Much is not told.
Here is part of the interview from James Miles of The Economis while he was in Tibet short while ago, which is only seen on-line. (Google james miles cnn).
'What I saw was calculated targeted violence against an ethnic group, or I should say two ethnic groups, primarily ethnic Han Chinese living in Lhasa, but also members of the Muslim Hui minority in Lhasa. And the Huis in Lhasa control much of the meat industry in the city. Those two groups were singled out by ethnic Tibetans. They marked those businesses that they knew to be Tibetan owned with white traditional scarves. Those businesses were left intact. Almost every single other across a wide swathe of the city, not only in the old Tibetan quarter, but also beyond it in areas dominated by the ethnic Han Chinese. Almost every other business was either burned, looted, destroyed, smashed into, the property therein hauled out into the streets, piled up, burned. It was an extraordinary outpouring of ethnic violence of a most unpleasant nature to watch, which surprised some Tibetans watching it. So they themselves were taken aback at the extent of what they saw. And it was not just targeted against property either. Of course many ethnic Han Chinese and Huis fled as soon as this broke out. But those who were caught in the early stages of it were themselves targeted. Stones thrown at them. At one point, I saw them throwing stones at a boy of maybe around 10 years old perhaps cycling along the street. I in fact walked out in front of them and said stop. It was a remarkable explosion of simmering ethnic grievances in the city.'
Any extrem nationalism, Tibetan, Chinese, or any other, is bad for the world. We are better off not to support any. Human rights for all, Tibetan and Chinese. If the media has been fair, it would not have inflammed the situation, as the public in the west are largely ill-informed, and some are easy to jump into the Chinese-hatred mood. The changein China has been great over the past 20 years. We want that to continue, not to stop. Hatred will only do more harm.

I would like to thanks all the people who had the greatest concern for the Chinese people. Yes, the CCP government apparently “tyrannizes” their own people: the Chinese. But today the “suppressed” are rallying around their “suppressor” and defending their government. Yes, they must be brainwashed. Don’t you see the logic?

Maybe you are still living in the cold war and watched too many 007 movies. Please come back to reality. If you truly concerned about the average Chinese living under the “tyranny”, come and visiting us in China. Because right now, I am not really feeling your concern is a genuine one, all I am feeling is the hatred towards China.

I am a Chinese living in US for over 25 years.
From reading the posts here, I am very sad. There is a huge gap
between West and China. Misunderstanding is perhaps an
understatement. If I open my mouth to talk about history, it will
not have much credit here given my Chinese background.
So perhaps you would allow me to start with a brief story.

The other day my grader, a 20 year old undergraduate student from
China came to my office to discuss her work. Instead, she was crying
and complaining about the attack on the Olympic torch. Chinese culture put higher value
in collectivity rather individuality. She donated all her allowance
several year ago in high school to the Olympic Games as millions of
other youngsters in their age did. Many these young Chinese do talk
about human rights just as those in West. Therefore, when they saw
some lama monks (from Youtube for example) burned children alive,
burned down schools and a mosque and killed people with knives in
the open streets in Lhasa, they expected the West media would
condemn them. What they saw in the West media was truly shocking to
them. When they saw a young Chinese girl with one leg on a wheel
chair holding the torch was attached in Paris, they took very
personally. My grader, in particular, never thought that there might
be any link between this attack and Chinese government's policy.
She believes these are well organized timed attacks to everything
she valued highest. She is not alone. Hundreds of millions
youngsters in China take the same view. They all take these attack
very personally.

I certainly believe that many in West who support the "Free Tibet"
movement are very sincere and care very much about human rights in
China. But millions of Chinese felt what happened in the last few week
is an attack on basic human rights, the rights of the victims of
those lamas monks with knives, the right of over billion people.
Their dedication to the Olympic Games, their dreams of a wonderful
party to show these young Chinese's openness to the world was
denied. They were deeply hurt. I am sure that this was not what
many people intended. The gap between East and West widened. I
myself choose to blame the media who plays a very ugly role in
these event.

Neil McGowan...why oh why do you see HATRED? I cannot understand you, if i speak for my country you see hatred? Why? You talk of blood, 'commies' etc, you assume that I am one of those hard liners eh? no, i am an ordinary person without any political leaning...you see how you assume so much Mr McGowan...it is YOU that is filled with hatred and fear and suspicion of China , you ar ea very ignorant man who is again a victim of his own version of events. Why speak of my family? What is this 'overthrowing 'you are talking about? Youar eso funny, we are very happy in China, we work hard, we live together, family is a very strong unit, we are mostly successful, I see jealousy in your words Mr Mc Gowan and the need to bully.

Date: 26 April 2008

Mr. Jacques Rogge
President
International Olympic Committee
Chateau de Vidy
1007 Lausanne
Switzerland

Dear Mr Rogge,

Re: Stop the Beijing Olympic Torch Relay going through Tibet

As you are well aware, the uprising of the people of Tibet against the blocking of religious practices by the occupation of Communist China has resulted in massive and merciless repression by the Chinese paramilitary forces; at least 150 confirmed deaths and at least 3400 arrests. These numbers are set to go up significantly as the days go by and we receive confirmed counts of Tibetan victims of Chinese brutality and repression.

Tibet was an independent state prior to 7th October 1950 with a long history and a distinct national identity independent of China. The 1951 Seventeen Point Agreement forced under duress by China, to incorporate Tibet as an Autonomous Region of China. In that Agreement, China had guaranteed Tibetan self-rule with no alteration of Tibetan political, cultural, and religious systems and institutions. The failure of the People's Republic of China to adhere to the Seventeen Point Agreement, and the imposition of the so-called social reforms, led to the Tibetan peoples uprising on 10th March 1959. The violent suppression by China forced HH the Dalai Lama and a large number of Tibetans to seek exile outside Tibet.

The large scale uprisings that took place in 1987, 1988 and 1989 and the more recent popular uprising that started on March 10th this year demanding autonomy, freedom, human rights and the return of HH the Dalai Lama, reflect the true aspirations and needs of the Tibetan people.

Since the revolt against Chinese rule in Tibet that began in early 1950s and through the end of the Cultural Revolution in 1976, an estimated 1,200,000 Tibetans, which is approximately one fifth of the Tibetan population, were killed and more than 6,000 religious sites destroyed. These religious sites are the seats of learning and the corner stone of Tibetan civilization and cultural heritage.

In 1959, 1960, and 1997 the International Commission of Jurists examined Chinese policy in Tibet, violations of human rights in Tibet, and the position of Tibet in international law and found that the People's Republic of China had committed "acts of genocide . . . in Tibet in an attempt to destroy and "re-educate" the Tibetans as a religious group" and that Tibet was at least "a de facto state" prior to 1951.


The United Nations General Assembly adopted resolutions in 1959, 1961, and 1965 calling on the People's Republic of China to ensure respect for fundamental human rights of the Tibetan people and for their distinctive cultural and religious life, and to cease practices which deprive the Tibetan people of their fundamental rights and freedoms, including the right to self-determination.

Truth and justice loving citizens of the world has spoken loud and clear in recent days against the Chinese government's inhuman and unjustifiable brutality inflicted upon the innocent and voiceless protestors and the violation of fundamental human rights of Tibetan people inside Tibet. The depth of concerns showed by the international community during the Olympic Torch relay through London, Paris, San Francisco, Buenos Aires and Delhi, has led the IOC to accept the fact that the Beijing Olympic "is a crisis, no doubt about it" for the Olympic movement.

You have further admitted that China has made a moral engagement and moral intention to improve human rights when it was given the Games. Clearly, China has failed to upheld these covenants, on the contrary their human rights record is far worse. Countless Chinese people have been evicted due to the Olympics and petitioners and their lawyers beaten and imprisoned. This week Chinese ships of weapons and ammunition have attempted to dock and unload weapons to Zimbabwe and contribute to further acts of genocide. Peace protesters attempts to hold up banners on Mount Everest, have been threatened to be shot. The government of Norway’s Minister of Foreign Affairs has raised concerns on their website:

"There are no laws, inadequate protection for the rights of individuals. Civil and political rights, such as freedom of expression, religion and organisation, in particular must be considerably strengthened. The re-education camps have yet to be closed. Minorities have yet to be afforded genuine protection of their culture and religion. Freedom of expression in China is under pressure. The lack of information from Tibetan areas is a problem. The extensive use of the death penalty is also a cause of concern. And I repeat, China must develop independent courts.”


In the current darkest hours of the Tibetans inside Tibet which is now like a huge military prison, you know very well that China is making a mockery of the spirit of the Olympics Games by turning it into a political circus show.

China has deliberately planned to take the Olympic torch through Tibet to make the political point that Tibet belongs to China whereas there is not a single legal document that legitimises China’s sovereign claims over Tibet.

If you do not want the athletes of the Olympics to be used as political bait then the first issue is with China and not the democratic right of the international community to voice concern under these disturbing circumstances. It is in our own fundamental self-interest to keep China involved in the international community, as a responsible member of the global community of nations playing according to international rules.


Therefore, I would like to appeal to the International Olympic Committee not to turn a blind eye to this blatant and provocative political act orchestrated by China. I would like to further request your good offices to exercise your power to reprimand the Chinese Government for bringing the Olympic Games into disrepute by using it for political gains. Most important of all, I urge you and the IOC, to demand the withdrawal of the proposed plan to take the Olympic Torch through Tibet. This is why Tibet has come up as an issue to mar the character of the Olympics. Please do not let the Olympic torch be used to condone 50 years of cultural genocide and human rights abuse in Tibet that has been acknowledged by the international community.


Otherwise, the IOC and your leadership will be directly responsible and accountable for the bloodshed of more innocent Tibetans in Tibet who are bound to protest against the Olympic Torch passing through Tibet.

As you will know Mr. Jampa Phuntsok, the Governor of Tibet Autonomous Region of China, during a press conference, has declared and warned the international community that they will use maximum force and powers of the State to deal with anyone who dares to protest against the Olympic Torch relay in Tibet.

I appeal to you with the hope that your moral responsibility for the human conscience and commitment to uphold the founding spirit of the Olympic Games will give you the courage and conviction to prevent the Olympic torch from contributing to further human rights abuse and causing more bloodshed in Tibet, the Land of Snows.

Stop the Olympic Torch relay from crossing Tibet

Danno, you haven't answered any of the points I made - you've just replied with an ad hominem attack. I realise of course that in China that's considered acceptable, but in democratic countries it is not.

I repeat - the Chinese Communist Party which you serve has murdered 47 million people during the C20th. There is no freedom of expression in China. There is no democracy in China. There have never been elections in Communist China. China is ruled by a one-party system in which crooks and communist thugs are given power over ordinary Chinese people.

"The need to bully", Danno?? Surely that's YOUR need, because I read your vicious thuggish threats in all your messages, and your personal attacks on everyone you reply to, and I see a thug Commissar.

To John Wang... well, I am really sorry your "grader" read and believed Communist Party *LIES* about what happened in Tibet. Unfortunately many Chinese people are brainwashed by commie lies. If she loves Commieland so much, why doesn't she GO AND LIVE THERE, because in the USA COMMIES aren't widely appreciated. Perhaps she should start a pro-Communist rally in America, and see what reaction she gets???

BTW, I have been in China seven times, and also I've been arrested by Chinese Police, and illegally held in a Chinese Police Station. I was arrested for no offence, except some illiterate thug (THE HEAD OF IMMIGRATION POLICE OF CITY OF HEIHE) claimed I had a "false passport". I still remember his angry red face shouting at me, and how he SPAT on me. That must be the "Chinese culture" you love - SPITTING on people???? So I know the Chinese commie thug police from personal experience.

China is a world leader and has made many great achievements - these should rightly be celebrated at the Olympics.

I will be celebrating the arrest of the world's youngest political prisoner, Gendun Chokyi Nyima, held by China from the age of six for the crime of being recognised as a reincarnation.
I will be celebrating the fact that China is the world leader in Capital punishment, executing more people per year than the total executed in the rest of the world.
I will also be celebrating the events of June 4th 1989.
When the rest of the world thinks of China, the first thing that springs to mind is the brutal suppression of its own people for the crime of asking for change.

Tibet is not a part of China.
China has occupied Tibet by force since 1950 and continues to do so.
The CPC can easily solve the Tibet issue by dialogue with the Dalai Lama but they refuse.

Here are some brainwashed Communist zealots. You can hear the hysteria and hatred in their voices:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vu52ON0JqY8

And here's the real face of Chinese Communist thug violence - a mob of Chinese Commies attacks a Tibetan in S Korea. Listen to the hatred in their voices as they capture him.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7lshw_PIVx8

But Danno won't reply to this. John Wang's "grader" won't watch this. Because it's the TRUTH that will never be seen on CCTV.

Neil, you are not telling the truth it is clear. Westerners are treated with respect in China and if you are arrested 7 times it is probably because you were drunk and disorderly like many ex pats living in Hong Kong and getting drunk all the time and trying to find prostitutes. Goodbye Neil we don't want you in China, it is clear why you write to this blog, you have big problem with another culture and maybe you feel very unsatisfied with your life. Sorry, wish you well to overcome hatred of other nation. Tibet is part of China and always will be. Sorry westeners, it is our land. Please give back the Falklands to Argentina maybe?

As I said Danno - you can't answer my points, so you reply with ad hominem attacks. All you do is devalue your own position still further when you do so. You're a paid commie liar, and lying is all you can do.

Personally I like Chinese people and wish them well. It is the oppressive policies of their government, and the propagandists who try to excuse it, that I oppose.

We like our government as you like your own; we are proud of our country as you are proud of your own; we do not admire propagandists as you do not; we are the same as you. We are people with a different political system and it is the same as your own but it goes under another name. Democracy is the type of government that allows everyone to be an oppressor on face value in other words you have 'freedom of speech' and can vent your views but if you really want to change anything you cannot; you cannot change your monarchy, you can not change the defence policies of your government, you cannot know what goes on in MI5 or MI6, you are very silly people because you think you are more free than China? You are not as educated as we are and we have a very long history...longer than your own; when we were creating literature and painting and music - you were rubbing flints together.

good point danno.
China has a long history, much of which is conveniently forgotten. The 2000 years of Buddhism that China shares with Tibet was crushed during the cultural revolution. The latest form of Government - ex marxist totalitarian capitalism - is being made up as it goes along.
If you had the courage, you could see that Chinese have more in common with the Tibetans than they do with the neu aristocracy in the CPC.
both are subjugated by the authoritarians in control. the only difference is the poor chinese would rather eat than be free where the Tibetans would rather be free than lose their religion.

Danno: "We like our government as you like your own;"

Evidently it has escaped Danno's notice that something like about half of us in democratic countries do NOT like our governments. I would say that significant numbers of us despise our governments. What's more, we are FREE TO SAY SO! And let us not overlook the fact that despising our governments does not conflict at all with loving our countries.

However, this discussion wasn't about democratic coutries. It was, and let it continue to be, about the actions and policies of a goverment in whose country dissent is brutally repressed by the agents of that government. And let it be noted once more that criticism of that government is not criticism of that country or of its people!

Thanks you again, you westerner who want to overthrow the Chinese government. Chinese government belongs to the Chinese people living in China. If Chinese people want to overthrown it, let them do. Right now we are happy with the government. They have made a huge progress for all Chinese in the last thirty years. Sure, it is not perfect one. In fact, we complained a lot about them. But why you want to force something on us that we don't want? Right now, a western-style democracy would mean chaos. We have seen what you did in Iraq and we understand all you care is what make you feel good.

I have always been amazed at Americans' inability to see the sheer hypocrisy of the "Free Tibet" movement. They, and the Canadian, Aussies and New Zealanders (i.e. the Anglo Saxons) essentially destroyed the native inhabitants of these lands and then forcefully occupied them. What is happening in Tibet may not be right but I truly believe if all of you went back to Europe or at least paid fair rents to the native Americans, Australians, Maoris, etc. then China may even withdraw from Tibet as she is shamed by your shining example. Only a mere 80 years separate Wounded Knee from Lhasa 1959. Surely America can at least give back everything from Chicago and west to the Native Americans - at least. Then we Chinese will listen to you as then, you would no longer by hypocrites.

Neil McGowan: I would like to apologize to you if the Chinese immigration officer mistreated you in the past. I disagree with my fellow Chinese friends and would welcome anyone visiting China with respect and warmth as our guest, including you regardless your political opinion. But this personal grudge does not give you a free license to insult all Chinese people for their intelligence on knowing what kind of government they want. They may not have all the information, but they see year by year that their daily live is improving. It is the basic human right that people don’t have to worry about putting the food on the table for their family and have some basic security around their homes. And the Chinese government is doing a great job improving it. We Chinese people are practical people, we don’t mind if the CCP continues to call themselves communist party because we know they are communist in name only. Please stop all your false pretence that you care about the lives of the average Chinese people. Because I know, deep in your heart, you don’t give a damn. If you want to talk about Tibet, then I am happy to discuss with you on Tibet.

>> Because I know, deep in your heart, you don’t give a damn. <<

Another ad-hominem attack, from another Communist zealot. When I need YOUR opinion on what's in MY heart, Dan, I'll ask you. Because just like the moron longnose-hating Immigration Officer who knew "better" than the staff of the Chinese Consulate in London that my passport was "forged", you are another Chinese know-all who hasn't a clue. I don't *want* or *need* your welcome, because my *friends* in China (who aren't Party Members) have always made me very welcome. Love the Chinese people. Hate the Commie thugs.

Watch this, Dan. Then try to deny it???

http://youtube.com/watch?v=x6M7NzTrrzs

Neil: with all you hatred and name calling, do you also pretend that you are a Buddhist or Christian that loves Dalai Lama? Give me a break.

We simply want to add another resource from the Tibetan voice in exile at http://www.tibetanphotoproject.com
The Tibetan Photo Project is working to create a voice directly from the exile community through their photos and films.

Dan, I realise that it's a complete novelty for you to have the chance to write your own opinion - after all, in Communist China, you cannot. But don't you think of the damage you do to China's reputation abroad, with every insult and with every lie you write? China is hurt by everything you say and do. Think about it.

I am not going to reply to you again - life is too full of interesting things to waste time on Communist clerks. So you and your friends TT, Julius, and Danno can write all the lies and insults you like. Just remember, each time you do so - China's reputation is injured some more.

Neil: Oh, yes, you care a great deal of China's reputation, thank you very much. I lived in UK once and have a great respect for your country and respect the BBC despite some recent hiccups. I know also that most Briton are not like you. But they do have some hooligans like we have ours (I am not proud of that, but I accept that is the reality). Calling everyone who has a different opinion "a communist", I start to wonder who is brainwashed.

Neil McGowan belongs back in the witch hunt anti-Communism McCarthy era of 1950's America; he is so busy insulting Chinese people here that he only thinks with a very small part of his brain that is located in the region that controls emotional intelligence; his is very low, he is angry with something that he knows nothing about. If you ever took time to read what we are saying then you could stop being so angry with the 'invisible' enemy. you are suffering from a psychological condition that is paranoia and persecution complex. Don't worry help is at hand - why not try some Chinese acupuncture for calming nerves or ancient Chinese Qigong, very good for helping to overcome the anxious and restless mind.

Haven't read all the posts above, but seems a lot wilder than what we have in Canada, which has had a fair amount of reaction to the Tibet-China issue. What I notice here more is the 'racial' quality of the comment. In a lot of cases, not much differentiation between the Beijing Regime and the Chinese people as a whole. Once this line is crossed, the matter begins to get confused, I feel. This goes for both sides of the arguments.

What I gather re. Dorje Shugden is that, apart from not cooperating with the Dalai Lama, which most practitioners of Tibetan Buddhism tend to do as a matter of principle (since cooperation and harmony are key in this religion), the group maintains a heretical form of practice that accesses the negative aspect of life energy in an incorrect way, detrimental to the true spirit of Buddhism. I don't expect most who live / have lived under the Beijing Regime to understand this, as they have been deprived of a spiritual life after Mao et al threw out the baby with the bathwater. However, I won't mind being corrected about Dorje Shugden from knowledgeable observers of this group.

Danno: "Chinese government belongs to the Chinese people living in China. If Chinese people want to overthrown it, let them do. Right now we are happy with the government. They have made a huge progress for all Chinese in the last thirty years. Sure, it is not perfect one. In fact, we complained a lot about them."

Yes, I remember: Tiananmen Square, 1989.

onnad: I am glad that you mentioned Tiananmen. You might be surprised if I tell you that I was a supporter of Tiananmen students and I have my personal grudges with the Chinese government. But I made peace with myself that it is time to move on. I don’t expect you would understand that.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YjJhiVC7_aw

Danno,

No you're wrong. The Dalai Lama, his tutors and all the great masters of the Gelug tradition practised Dorje Shugden. It's hard to know where to start but you could do worse than watching this 1998 Swiss documentary on the issue:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n5sOm-uQH9Y


Post a comment